Section 117 of the Australian Constitution provides: “A subject of the Queen, resident in any State, shall not be subject in any other State to any disability or discrimination which would not be equally applicable to him if he were a subject of the Queen resident in such other State”.
The Rules of Court for Barristers applying for admission in Queensland were held to not apply to Mr Street as they contravened s117 of the Constitution by requiring him to have an intention of practising principally in Queensland.
Jones was an adult who received serious injuries when he walked through an interior glass door at the house where he lived with his parents. The house was rented from Bartlett and another by the plaintiff’s parents.
Jones sued Bartlett for damages, alleging negligence, breach of statutory duty and breach of contract. The District Court awarded Jones damages, holding that Bartlett was negligent. The Full Court of the Supreme Court of Western Australia allowed an appeal. Jones then appealed to the High Court, who dismissed his appeal.
The High Court found that the premises were not defective and held that there was no negligence, breach of statutory duty or breach of duty of care on the part of Bartlett.
A landlord’s duty to take reasonable care to avoid foreseeable risk of injury does not require it to make residential premises as safe as reasonable care could make them: per Gaudron J at [87]. The duty owed to the tenants concerns what a reasonable person would do in response to a foreseeable risk of injury.
Per Gleeson CJ:
“There is no ground in principle for imposing upon the respondents an obligation greater than an obligation to take reasonable care to avoid foreseeable risk of injury to their prospective tenants and members of their household. The critical question is as to what is reasonable. The judgment of the Full Court, with which I agree, to the effect that there was no failure to take reasonable care, was a judgment of fact. It cannot be circumvented by an attempt to formulate the legal duty with greater particularity, in a manner which seeks to pre-empt the decision as to reasonableness.” at [57].
“There is no such thing as absolute safety. All residential premises contain hazards to their occupants and to visitors. Most dwelling houses could be made safer, if safety were the only consideration. The fact that a house could be made safer does not mean it is dangerous or defective. Safety standards imposed by legislation or regulation recognise a need to balance safety with other factors, including cost, convenience, aesthetics and practicality.The standards in force at the time of the lease reflect this. They did not require thicker or tougher glass to be put into the door that caused the injury unless, for some reason, the glass had to be replaced. That, it is true, is merely the way the standards were framed, and it does not pre-empt the common law. But it reflects common sense. ” at [23].
LEGAL HELPDESK LAWYERS is a new generation private legal practice that offers legal guidance to individuals and businesses in Sydney’s Lower North Shore and Northern Beaches.
We provide information, advice and advocacy to those who need – or might need – legal representation in any area of law.
If required, we refer customers to a reliable network of specialist lawyers. We take the guesswork out of finding a good lawyer.
Legal Helpdesk is at Bridgepoint Mosman near the Level 1 footbridge to Fitness First
Our mission is to promote better local access to good legal help.
Confidentiality and privacy is protected by law.
1300 00 2088
SYDNEY, AUSTRALIA
1300 00 2088
ALL AREAS OF LAW administrative law, advice, advocacy, animal law, arbitration, attorneys, aviation law, banking and finance, bankruptcy, barristers, business law, breach of duty of care, civil liability, civil litigation, commercial law, commercial leases, common law, communications law, company law, compensation, conciliation, consumer law, contract, conveyancing, copyright, corporate law, corporations law, costs, criminal law, criminal litigation, death and disability, debt recovery, defamation law, disability discrimination law, discrimination, dispute resolution, divorce, elder law, employment law, environmental law, equity, estate planning, ethics, family law, guardianship, harassment and workplace bullying, health law, human rights, immigration, industrial law, insolvency, intellectual property, labour law, land and environment court, land law, landlord and tenant, lawyer referral, lawyers, leases, licensing law, liquor law, litigation, local government, malpractice, media law, mediation, medical law, mortgages, motor vehicle law, negligence, occupational health and safety law, partnerships, planning law, powers of attorney, privacy law, pro bono, probate law, professional negligence, professional standards, property law, residential leases, revenue law, securities law, settlements, shipping law, social security, solicitors, sports law, succession, superannuation law, tax law, torts, total and permanent disablement, traffic law, transport law, wills, workplace law
LEGAL HELPDESK LAWYERS is a new generation private legal practice that offers legal guidance to individuals and businesses in Sydney’s Lower North Shore and Northern Beaches.
We provide information, advice and advocacy to those who need – or might need – legal representation in any area of law.
If required, we refer customers to a reliable network of specialist lawyers. We take the guesswork out of finding a good lawyer.
Legal Helpdesk is at Bridgepoint Mosman near the Level 1 footbridge to Fitness First
Our mission is to promote better local access to good legal help.
Confidentiality and privacy is protected by law.
1300 00 2088
SYDNEY, AUSTRALIA
1300 00 2088
ALL AREAS OF LAW administrative law, advice, advocacy, animal law, arbitration, attorneys, aviation law, banking and finance, bankruptcy, barristers, business law, breach of duty of care, civil liability, civil litigation, commercial law, commercial leases, common law, communications law, company law, compensation, conciliation, consumer law, contract, conveyancing, copyright, corporate law, corporations law, costs, criminal law, criminal litigation, death and disability, debt recovery, defamation law, disability discrimination law, discrimination, dispute resolution, divorce, elder law, employment law, environmental law, equity, estate planning, ethics, family law, guardianship, harassment and workplace bullying, health law, human rights, immigration, industrial law, insolvency, intellectual property, labour law, land and environment court, land law, landlord and tenant, lawyer referral, lawyers, leases, licensing law, liquor law, litigation, local government, malpractice, media law, mediation, medical law, mortgages, motor vehicle law, negligence, occupational health and safety law, partnerships, planning law, powers of attorney, privacy law, pro bono, probate law, professional negligence, professional standards, property law, residential leases, revenue law, securities law, settlements, shipping law, social security, solicitors, sports law, succession, superannuation law, tax law, torts, total and permanent disablement, traffic law, transport law, wills, workplace law
LEGAL HELPDESK LAWYERS is a new generation private legal practice that offers legal guidance to individuals and businesses in Sydney’s Lower North Shore and Northern Beaches.
We provide information, advice and advocacy to those who need – or might need – legal representation in any area of law.
If required, we refer customers to a reliable network of specialist lawyers. We take the guesswork out of finding a good lawyer.
Legal Helpdesk is at Bridgepoint Mosman near the Level 1 footbridge to Fitness First
Our mission is to promote better local access to good legal help.
Confidentiality and privacy is protected by law.
1300 00 2088
SYDNEY, AUSTRALIA
1300 00 2088
ALL AREAS OF LAW administrative law, advice, advocacy, animal law, arbitration, attorneys, aviation law, banking and finance, bankruptcy, barristers, business law, breach of duty of care, civil liability, civil litigation, commercial law, commercial leases, common law, communications law, company law, compensation, conciliation, consumer law, contract, conveyancing, copyright, corporate law, corporations law, costs, criminal law, criminal litigation, death and disability, debt recovery, defamation law, disability discrimination law, discrimination, dispute resolution, divorce, elder law, employment law, environmental law, equity, estate planning, ethics, family law, guardianship, harassment and workplace bullying, health law, human rights, immigration, industrial law, insolvency, intellectual property, labour law, land and environment court, land law, landlord and tenant, lawyer referral, lawyers, leases, licensing law, liquor law, litigation, local government, malpractice, media law, mediation, medical law, mortgages, motor vehicle law, negligence, occupational health and safety law, partnerships, planning law, powers of attorney, privacy law, pro bono, probate law, professional negligence, professional standards, property law, residential leases, revenue law, securities law, settlements, shipping law, social security, solicitors, sports law, succession, superannuation law, tax law, torts, total and permanent disablement, traffic law, transport law, wills, workplace law
LEGAL HELPDESK LAWYERS is a new generation private legal practice that offers legal guidance to individuals and businesses in Sydney’s Lower North Shore and Northern Beaches.
We provide information, advice and advocacy to those who need – or might need – legal representation in any area of law.
If required, we refer customers to a reliable network of specialist lawyers. We take the guesswork out of finding a good lawyer.
Legal Helpdesk is at Bridgepoint Mosman near the Level 1 footbridge to Fitness First
Our mission is to promote better local access to good legal help.
Confidentiality and privacy is protected by law.
1300 00 2088
SYDNEY, AUSTRALIA
1300 00 2088
ALL AREAS OF LAW administrative law, advice, advocacy, animal law, arbitration, attorneys, aviation law, banking and finance, bankruptcy, barristers, business law, breach of duty of care, civil liability, civil litigation, commercial law, commercial leases, common law, communications law, company law, compensation, conciliation, consumer law, contract, conveyancing, copyright, corporate law, corporations law, costs, criminal law, criminal litigation, death and disability, debt recovery, defamation law, disability discrimination law, discrimination, dispute resolution, divorce, elder law, employment law, environmental law, equity, estate planning, ethics, family law, guardianship, harassment and workplace bullying, health law, human rights, immigration, industrial law, insolvency, intellectual property, labour law, land and environment court, land law, landlord and tenant, lawyer referral, lawyers, leases, licensing law, liquor law, litigation, local government, malpractice, media law, mediation, medical law, mortgages, motor vehicle law, negligence, occupational health and safety law, partnerships, planning law, powers of attorney, privacy law, pro bono, probate law, professional negligence, professional standards, property law, residential leases, revenue law, securities law, settlements, shipping law, social security, solicitors, sports law, succession, superannuation law, tax law, torts, total and permanent disablement, traffic law, transport law, wills, workplace law
LEGAL HELPDESK LAWYERS is a new generation private legal practice that offers legal guidance to individuals and businesses in Sydney’s Lower North Shore and Northern Beaches.
We provide information, advice and advocacy to those who need – or might need – legal representation in any area of law.
If required, we refer customers to a reliable network of specialist lawyers. We take the guesswork out of finding a good lawyer.
Legal Helpdesk is at Bridgepoint Mosman near the Level 1 footbridge to Fitness First
Our mission is to promote better local access to good legal help.
Confidentiality and privacy is protected by law.
1300 00 2088
SYDNEY, AUSTRALIA
1300 00 2088
ALL AREAS OF LAW administrative law, advice, advocacy, animal law, arbitration, attorneys, aviation law, banking and finance, bankruptcy, barristers, business law, breach of duty of care, civil liability, civil litigation, commercial law, commercial leases, common law, communications law, company law, compensation, conciliation, consumer law, contract, conveyancing, copyright, corporate law, corporations law, costs, criminal law, criminal litigation, death and disability, debt recovery, defamation law, disability discrimination law, discrimination, dispute resolution, divorce, elder law, employment law, environmental law, equity, estate planning, ethics, family law, guardianship, harassment and workplace bullying, health law, human rights, immigration, industrial law, insolvency, intellectual property, labour law, land and environment court, land law, landlord and tenant, lawyer referral, lawyers, leases, licensing law, liquor law, litigation, local government, malpractice, media law, mediation, medical law, mortgages, motor vehicle law, negligence, occupational health and safety law, partnerships, planning law, powers of attorney, privacy law, pro bono, probate law, professional negligence, professional standards, property law, residential leases, revenue law, securities law, settlements, shipping law, social security, solicitors, sports law, succession, superannuation law, tax law, torts, total and permanent disablement, traffic law, transport law, wills, workplace law
LEGAL HELPDESK LAWYERS is a new generation private legal practice that offers legal guidance to individuals and businesses in Sydney’s Lower North Shore and Northern Beaches.
We provide information, advice and advocacy to those who need – or might need – legal representation in any area of law.
If required, we refer customers to a reliable network of specialist lawyers. We take the guesswork out of finding a good lawyer.
Legal Helpdesk is at Bridgepoint Mosman near the Level 1 footbridge to Fitness First
Our mission is to promote better local access to good legal help.
Confidentiality and privacy is protected by law.
1300 00 2088
SYDNEY, AUSTRALIA
1300 00 2088
ALL AREAS OF LAW administrative law, advice, advocacy, animal law, arbitration, attorneys, aviation law, banking and finance, bankruptcy, barristers, business law, breach of duty of care, civil liability, civil litigation, commercial law, commercial leases, common law, communications law, company law, compensation, conciliation, consumer law, contract, conveyancing, copyright, corporate law, corporations law, costs, criminal law, criminal litigation, death and disability, debt recovery, defamation law, disability discrimination law, discrimination, dispute resolution, divorce, elder law, employment law, environmental law, equity, estate planning, ethics, family law, guardianship, harassment and workplace bullying, health law, human rights, immigration, industrial law, insolvency, intellectual property, labour law, land and environment court, land law, landlord and tenant, lawyer referral, lawyers, leases, licensing law, liquor law, litigation, local government, malpractice, media law, mediation, medical law, mortgages, motor vehicle law, negligence, occupational health and safety law, partnerships, planning law, powers of attorney, privacy law, pro bono, probate law, professional negligence, professional standards, property law, residential leases, revenue law, securities law, settlements, shipping law, social security, solicitors, sports law, succession, superannuation law, tax law, torts, total and permanent disablement, traffic law, transport law, wills, workplace law
At Legal Helpdesk we provide legal information and advice to local individuals and businesses on Sydney’s Lower North Shore and Northern Beaches. We triage all types of matters and if required refer them to a network of reliable solicitors and barristers with suitable expertise.
Our aim is to make it easier for people to find the right information, advice and results.
Confidentiality and privacy is protected by law.
1300 00 2088
Sydney, Australia
Connect, follow, like, join, share etc
ALL AREAS OF LAW administrative law, advice, advocacy, animal law, arbitration, attorneys, aviation law, banking and finance, bankruptcy, barristers, business law, breach of duty of care, civil liability, civil litigation, commercial law, commercial leases, common law, communications law, company law, compensation, conciliation, consumer law, contract, conveyancing, copyright, corporate law, corporations law, costs, criminal law, criminal litigation, death and disability, debt recovery, defamation law, disability discrimination law, discrimination, dispute resolution, divorce, elder law, employment law, environmental law, equity, estate planning, ethics, family law, guardianship, harassment and workplace bullying, health law, human rights, immigration, industrial law, insolvency, intellectual property, labour law, land and environment court, land law, landlord and tenant, lawyer referral, lawyers, leases, licensing law, liquor law, litigation, local government, malpractice, media law, mediation, medical law, mortgages, motor vehicle law, negligence, occupational health and safety law, partnerships, planning law, powers of attorney, privacy law, pro bono, probate law, professional negligence, professional standards, property law, residential leases, revenue law, securities law, settlements, shipping law, social security, solicitors, sports law, succession, superannuation law, tax law, torts, total and permanent disablement, traffic law, transport law, wills, workplace law